Local Thanksgiving


When you come to our farm store to pick up your turkeys and pies you’ll be able to find more local goodies to complete your Thanksgiving meal. Our farm store will be fully stocked with Thanksgiving essentials like our homemade stuffing kits, homemade cranberry saucefresh local cranberries, our apples, certified organic veggies & eggs, fresh-pressed cider, hard cider, wine, spirits and so much more! We will also have a limited selection of pies (baked & frozen) available for purchase in our farm store.


Order Deadlines:
Turkey and Fishkill Farms Pie orders are closed. We still have some gluten-free pies and cranberry sauce available for pre-order. We will have a limited number of pies available to purchase in our farm store throughout the days leading up to Thanksgiving but we cannot accept any more pre-orders for pies. We will also have cranberry sauce, fresh cranberries, stuffing kits (in addition to our normal store offerings) available in our farm store. 

Pickup Times:
Turkeys, Pies and anything ordered on the “Thanksgiving” tab can be picked up starting on Sunday, Nov. 22nd and Tuesday, Nov. 24th  from 9 am-5:30pm and Wednesday, Nov. 25th. from 9 am-2:30 pm. We are closing at 3pm on Wednesday, Nov. 25th.

Refund Policy 
Payments of Thanksgiving orders and deposits are non-refundable after Monday, November 16th.



We source our Turkeys locally from Pick of The Pasture Farm located in Greenwich New York. Much like our chickens, these turkeys were pasture-raised and live in mobile coops which are moved around so they can enjoy pecking and foraging at new pieces of land. The pasture mix consists of clover, alfalfa, timothy and orchard grass, which provides an excellent diet high in protein for helping them grow.

Turkey Payment
The price you are charged through the website is a deposit for your Turkey. You will be charged the remainder of the price for the Turkey depending on the final weight of your Turkey. Turkeys are $5.99/pound. CSA Members must enter their CSA code at checkout to receive their discount. 



Fishkill Farms Homemade Pies

Fishkill Farms’ Homemade pies are made with fresh ingredients, from our own fruit where applicable, and with a real butter crust!

**We recommend if you are celebrating Thanksgiving on Thursday, Nov. 26th but picking up your pie Sunday-Tuesday, that you purchase a frozen pie and bake it fresh at home. Instructions for baking are below.

Pecan & Chocolate Pecan pies are not available frozen.

Nut Warning:
Customers should be aware that all pies are prepared in a kitchen handling nuts. We do our best to reduce the risk of cross-contamination, though it is always a possibility.

What is a Bumbleberry Pie?

Bumbleberry pie contains strawberries, blueberries, raspberries and blackberries.

Frozen Pie Baking Instructions

Mad Batters Pastries Gluten-Free Pies

We’ve partnered with Hudson Valley’s Mad Batter Pastries to bring you gluten-free pie options for your local Thanksgiving. These pies are baked in small batches in a gluten-free kitchen using fresh, local ingredients.



Translate »