Holiday Pie Orders




Fishkill Farms’ Homemade pies are made with fresh ingredients, from our own fruit where applicable, and with a real butter crust!

We recommend picking up your fresh-baked pie within 1-3 days of when you are planning on eating it. Otherwise, we recommend purchasing a frozen pie and baking it at home (we will provide you with instructions). When you purchase a frozen pie, the pie is raw and can be easily baked up fresh in an hour.

Our pies are made with real, fresh ingredients and are free from preservatives.  If you choose to purchase your pie baked and are not enjoying it the day you pick it up, we recommend placing your pie in the refrigerator.


We sourced our turkeys locally from Northwind Farm in Tivoli New York. Much like our chickens, these turkeys were pasture-raised and live in mobile coops which are moved around so they can enjoy pecking and foraging at new pieces of land.

Turkey Payment
The price you are charged through the website is a deposit for your turkey. You will be charged the remainder of the price for your turkey depending on the final weight of your Turkey at pickup. Turkeys are $6.99/pound.

Turkeys were freshly frozen by Northwind this fall.


Order Deadlines:
Pie orders must be in by Thursday, December 14th. Pies may not be canceled/refunded after Thursday, December 14th.

Pickup Times:
Pie pickup dates are Wednesday, Dec. 20th  through Saturday, December 23rd from 9 am- 5:30 pm


What is a Bumbleberry Pie? Bumbleberry pie contains strawberries, blueberries, raspberries and blackberries.

Nut Warning: Customers should be aware that all pies are prepared in a kitchen handling nuts. We do our best to reduce the risk of cross-contamination, though it is always a possibility. Cherry Pies contain almond extract.

Frozen Pie Baking Instructions

Translate »
Skip to content