SHOP HERE
HOMEMADE PIES
Fishkill Farms’ Homemade pies are made with fresh ingredients, are free from preservatives, and include our own fruit where applicable, all surrounded by a real butter crust.
From farm classics like Apple and Bumbleberry to holiday favorites like Apple Fig Walnut and Pumpkin Gingerbread, you’re sure to please your holiday guests. If you’re looking for a pie that’s not on our list, give us a shout via email at store@fishkillfarms.com and we may be able to accommodate your request.
BAKED or FROZEN
We offer our pies either freshly baked by us, or frozen and ready for your oven.
We recommend picking up your fresh-baked pie within 1-3 days of when you are planning on eating it. If you purchase your pie baked and are not enjoying it the day you pick it up, we recommend storing it in the refrigerator.
When you purchase a frozen pie, the pie is raw and can be easily baked in an hour. Frozen pies must remain frozen until ready to bake. We will provide you with a baking card with instructions.
Pecan & Chocolate Pecan pies are not available frozen.
PICK UP TIMES & ORDER DEADLINES
Order Deadlines:
Pie orders must be in by EOD Sunday, December 14th. Pies cannot be canceled/refunded after December 14th.
Pickup Times:
• Saturday, December 20th – 9:00 am-5:00 pm
• Sunday, December 21st – 9:00 am-5:00 pm
• Tuesday, December 23rd – 9:00 am-4:30 pm.
Nut Warning:
Customers should be aware that all pies are prepared in a kitchen handling nuts. We do our best to reduce the risk of cross-contamination, though it is always a possibility. Cherry Pies contain almond extract.
FAQ’s
What is a Bumbleberry Pie? Bumbleberry pie is a mixed fruit pie that contains strawberries, blueberries, raspberries and blackberries.
Do I have to bake a frozen pie? Yes, frozen pies are raw and should not be consumed until they are properly baked.
